Based Loaded - Third Out on Fielder's Choice
Posted: Wed Aug 01, 2012 2:31 pm
I think this might be an enhancement request.
This applies to a situation where the bases are loaded with two outs.
The batter hits the ball to shortstop who flips to third base for the force out. Inning over.
So I hit the "in play" button
For the batter they are SAFE and I push the FIELDER'S CHOICE button.
I record the location of the hit - to the short stop
I record the 6-5 as the players making the outs.
It then asks me - what happened to the runner on third?
The default choice is HOME and SAFE.
Lets ignore what I chose.
Next it asks what happened to the runner on second?
I pick OUT and then FORCE OUT
Here is my beef. The third out has been recorded on a force play. Regardless of what I happened to choose for the runner on third, no run should be scored by the application. So even if I mess up (guess what - I did twice in the same game) and say the runner on third was SAFE at HOME the application should be smart enough to over-rule.
So lets go back to the choices for the runner at third.
The default is SAFE at HOME. Changing the SAFE to OUT is wrong - because no out was recorded at home.
So now I'm thinking SAFE at HOME - seems wrong too!
One correct choice appears to be SAFE at HOME and push the RUN NOT SCORED button. This is not really an obvious choice though. I know now it is correct after playing with the application. At the time I didn't see the button. We've all been there.
Another correct choice appears to be SAFE at THIRD and HELD UP. Again not obvious.
At any rate, I messed up and now my score is wrong. I have an extra run. So I can go to the pitch-by-pitch and fix this right? No I cannot. I could not remove the run, even though I could push the RUN NOT SCORED button in the application it would not subtract the run.
So my two requests are
a) Please do not score any runs when the third out is a force out
b) Allow me to use the RUN NOT SCORED button in the pitch-by-pitch view to fix this.
Thanks!
This applies to a situation where the bases are loaded with two outs.
The batter hits the ball to shortstop who flips to third base for the force out. Inning over.
So I hit the "in play" button
For the batter they are SAFE and I push the FIELDER'S CHOICE button.
I record the location of the hit - to the short stop
I record the 6-5 as the players making the outs.
It then asks me - what happened to the runner on third?
The default choice is HOME and SAFE.
Lets ignore what I chose.
Next it asks what happened to the runner on second?
I pick OUT and then FORCE OUT
Here is my beef. The third out has been recorded on a force play. Regardless of what I happened to choose for the runner on third, no run should be scored by the application. So even if I mess up (guess what - I did twice in the same game) and say the runner on third was SAFE at HOME the application should be smart enough to over-rule.
So lets go back to the choices for the runner at third.
The default is SAFE at HOME. Changing the SAFE to OUT is wrong - because no out was recorded at home.
So now I'm thinking SAFE at HOME - seems wrong too!
One correct choice appears to be SAFE at HOME and push the RUN NOT SCORED button. This is not really an obvious choice though. I know now it is correct after playing with the application. At the time I didn't see the button. We've all been there.
Another correct choice appears to be SAFE at THIRD and HELD UP. Again not obvious.
At any rate, I messed up and now my score is wrong. I have an extra run. So I can go to the pitch-by-pitch and fix this right? No I cannot. I could not remove the run, even though I could push the RUN NOT SCORED button in the application it would not subtract the run.
So my two requests are
a) Please do not score any runs when the third out is a force out
b) Allow me to use the RUN NOT SCORED button in the pitch-by-pitch view to fix this.
Thanks!